Seriously, there's a bajillion webpages and reviews out there. How many do you trust? What about your fellow UChicago students?
If you love an anime and want to pimp it, create a page! If you want to warn against an anime, do that too!
Berserk (Berserk) to be written someday by Stephen or anyone else that loves it
Death Note (Death Note), originally by Stephen
Detective Conan (Meitantei Conan), to be written soon by Jono, but written by Dimi.
Escaflowne (Tenkuu no Esukafurone), to be written soon by Jono
Galaxy Express 999 (Ginga Tetsudou 999), to be written soon by Jono
Gatchaman (Kagaku Ninjatai Gatchaman), to be written soon by Jono
Giant Robo, to be written soon by Jono
Gurren Lagann, written by Hong
Hajime no Ippo, written by Hong
His and Her Circumstances (Kareshi Kanojou no Jijou, or KareKano) to be touched up by someone who actually remembers this series.
Honey and Clover (Hachimitsu to Kurobaa, or HachiKuro), mostly by Sushu
Ideon: Be Invoked, written by Dan H
Lupin III, to be written soon by Jono
Macross, written by professional resume writer Jon
Magic Knight Rayearth, written by Hong
Mobile Suit Gundam (Kidou Senshi Gandamu), written by Dan H
Now and Then Here and There (ima, soko ni iru boku, or ImaSoko), to be written soon by Sushu
Kino's Journey (Kino no Tabi), mostly by Brian
Paranoia Agent, to be written soon by Jono
Phoenix (Hi no Tori), to be written soon by Jono
Read or Die OVA, originally by Brian
Revolutionary Girl Utena (Shoujo Kakumei Utena), mostly by Brian
Romeo x Juliet, by Hong
Rose of Versailles (Berusai no Bara), to be written soon by somebody who has seen the ending... please?
Rozen Maiden, written by Hong
Seto no Hanayome, written by Hong
Space Battleship Yamato (Uchuu Senkan Yamato), mostly by Jono
Scrapped Princess, written by Hong
Space Runaway Ideon (Legendary Great God Ideon/Densetsu Kyojin Ideon), written by Dan H